After a few months of experimenting, plenty of flour-covered benches and more pizzas than I can count, I think I've finally landed on a pizza dough recipe I'm genuinely happy with.
I've made over 100 pizzas across roughly 20 sessions in the last few months. I've tried different ingredients, hydration levels, fermentation times and techniques. Some batches have been great, others... not so much.
But I've learned a lot along the way, and I've come back to one recipe that consistently delivers the results I'm after.
The interesting thing? It's not just about getting the ingredients right. It's about the order you add them, how you mix them and how you treat the dough along the way.
Here's what I'm currently using.
The ingredients
This recipe makes six dough balls, weighing approximately 270g each.
-
1kg high-protein 00 flour – Make sure it's a high-protein variety. Not all 00 flour is created equal.
-
630g cold water – Cold is important. More on that shortly.
-
1.5–2g instant yeast
-
20g salt
One thing I can't stress enough: weigh everything.
I use digital kitchen scales for every ingredient. Measuring by eye might work for some things, but when it comes to pizza dough, consistency matters. A small difference in water or flour can change how your dough behaves.
The method: It's all in the technique
I've got a mixer sitting there ready to go, but I've actually found that hand-kneading gives me the best results.
There's something about being able to feel the dough develop that makes a difference. You can tell when it's too sticky, when it needs more kneading and when it's starting to come together.
Here's how I do it.
1. Start with cold water
Grab a large mixing bowl and pour in your 630g of cold water.
I specifically use cold water rather than warm or hot water. Between the mixing process and the friction created during kneading, the dough can heat up surprisingly quickly.
Temperature is something I've learned to pay close attention to.
2. Dilute the flour
Add approximately 100–150g of flour to the water.
Using one hand, mix it through until the flour is diluted into the water.
Next, add your 20g of salt and mix it through until dissolved.
Then add your 1.5–2g of instant yeast, give it a stir and let everything sit for a couple of minutes.
3. Slowly bring the dough together
Now comes the fun part.
Start gradually adding the remaining flour, roughly 100–200g at a time, while slowly mixing everything together.
Don't rush this stage.
You'll probably find the dough starts sticking to the sides of the bowl. That's completely normal. Keep mixing and working it around until it starts forming a rough dough ball.
Once most of the loose flour has been incorporated, transfer the dough onto your bench.
Add any remaining loose flour from the bowl onto the dough.
4. Hand-knead, but watch the temperature
This is where I prefer to get hands-on.
Start kneading the dough, working everything together until it becomes smoother and more consistent.
One of my biggest lessons has been learning not to overheat the dough.
I actually use a probe thermometer to check its temperature. My target is to keep it below 25°C.
If it starts getting too warm, stop kneading and let it rest for a few minutes to cool down. You can also place a damp, cold cloth over it to help cool it while preventing the surface from drying out.
If it's feeling too sticky, don't immediately start throwing extra flour at it. Sometimes all it needs is a few minutes sitting on the bench to dry out slightly.
As long as the temperature is under 25°C, keep kneading.
Depending on how the dough is behaving, this might take anywhere from 3–10 minutes.
You should gradually notice it becoming smoother, softer and more elastic. That's exactly what you're looking for.
5. Let the dough rest
Once you're happy with the consistency, bring everything together into one large dough ball.
Cover it with a damp cloth and leave it on the bench for approximately two hours.
The damp cloth is important because you don't want the outside of the dough drying out and forming a crust.
This initial rest gives the yeast time to get working and allows the dough to start expanding.
6. Divide into six dough balls
After approximately two hours, it's time to divide the dough.
You should get six portions weighing around 270g each.
I recommend using a proper dough cutter or scraper. It makes clean cuts without unnecessarily pulling or tearing the dough structure.
Once you've divided the dough, it's time to form your individual balls.
I won't go too far into the balling technique here because it's much easier to show than explain. I've got videos on my social channels demonstrating how I fold, tuck and pinch the dough into individual balls.
The goal is to create a nice, smooth outer surface with some tension in the dough.
7. Into the containers
Get six suitable dough containers and give the inside a light spray with olive oil spray.
I also spray the inside of the lids, just in case the dough rises enough to make contact with them.
Place each dough ball inside its container, making sure there's enough room for it to expand. Ideally, allow for the dough to potentially double in size.
Seal the containers and leave them on the bench for approximately another hour.
This gives them a little more time to rise before heading into the fridge.
8. Cold fermentation: Where the magic happens
Now it's time to let the fridge do its thing.
I leave my dough balls in the fridge for a minimum of 24 hours.
My preference is around 48 hours, although 72 hours works too.
Longer fermentation gives the dough more time to develop flavour and character. It's one of the things I've really come to appreciate through experimenting with different batches.
There's no need to overcomplicate it. All three timeframes can work, and you can experiment to find what you prefer.
9. Get them out before cooking
This is an important step.
Take your dough balls out of the fridge approximately three hours before you're planning to cook.
Cold dough can be difficult to stretch, so giving it time to come back towards room temperature allows it to relax and makes it much easier to work with.
By the time you're ready to make your pizzas, you should have dough that's relaxed, soft and much easier to stretch.
And then it's time to get cooking.
What I've learned along the way
If there's one thing I've taken away from making more than 100 pizzas, it's that a good dough recipe is about much more than the ingredient list.
A few things I'd encourage anyone experimenting with pizza dough to remember:
-
Use scales. Don't guess your measurements.
-
Use high-protein 00 flour. The type of flour matters.
-
Keep your water cold. Dough temperature can climb quickly during mixing and kneading.
-
Watch the temperature. I aim to keep mine below 25°C.
-
Don't rush the kneading. Let the dough develop properly.
-
Give it time. Cold fermentation is worth experimenting with.
-
Don't panic if it's sticky. A little resting time can make a big difference.
I'm certainly not claiming to be a pizza dough expert. I'm just a bloke with a pizza oven who's become slightly obsessed with getting things right.
But after all the experimenting, this is the recipe and technique I'm coming back to.
And that's probably the best recommendation I can give it.
Now, time to turn those dough balls into pizza.
If you've got a favourite technique, a different fermentation method or a tip that you swear by, I'd love to hear about it. That's what The Inner Crust is all about – sharing what we're learning and getting better together.
Happy dough making!
Cheers,
Steve
Aussie Dough Dad
Sign-up to our free email list for more articles and free stuff - Join The Inner Crust here